Researchers Sorkkila and Aunola at the University of Jyväskylä asked 1,725 Finnish parents about burnout and what surrounded it. Several things were associated with parental burnout: the parent's age, unemployment, a family budget the parent saw as tight, and a child with special needs.
The researchers still identified one experience as the more crucial risk factor: the parent's sense that other people expected perfection of them.
Psychologists call this socially prescribed perfectionism, and it differs from ambition. An ambitious parent sets the bar and can lower it again. With socially prescribed perfectionism, the bar seems to come from elsewhere: relatives, other parents, the way everyone else's family life looks from the outside. That kind of bar is hard to lower on your own.
The study measured what parents felt, not what anyone around them actually thought. Some expectations are spoken and some are assumed. They weigh the same.
The link with burnout was stronger among parents who also held high standards of their own. The heaviest combination appears to be the one in which an outside standard is never questioned, because it already matches the parent's idea of what a good parent does.
The data have clear limits. A survey shows associations, not which came first; an exhausted parent may also experience the world as more demanding. And 91 percent of respondents were mothers.
The pressure attaches to work nobody sees
What does the perfect parent that others supposedly expect actually look like? Rarely the one who vacuums most. More often the one who remembers everything: rain gear before the rain, a present before the party, the form before the deadline.
This remembering has a structure in research. In Allison Daminger's interviews with 35 couples, the thinking work fell into four parts: anticipating a need, identifying options, deciding and monitoring. Women carried more of it overall, especially the anticipating and monitoring. Decisions were shared roughly equally. We cover this structure in more detail in the Finnish feature Perheen käyttöjärjestelmä (The family operating system).
That split matters. A decision is visible and can be discussed. Anticipating and monitoring happen before and after it, often inside one person's head, and that is where the demand for perfection takes hold. Nothing may be forgotten, and nothing may go unchecked.
Burnout tracked the thinking work, not the physical work
In a US research team's survey, 322 mothers of young children reported who in their household plans and who carries out 30 household tasks. On average, the mothers did about 73 percent of the planning and 64 percent of the doing.
The larger a mother's share of the planning, the more depression, stress and burnout she reported, and the lower she rated her relationship. Her share of the physical work was related only to relationship quality.
The design is cross-sectional and does not show cause and effect. It does show where to look when trying to understand exhaustion: less at the task list, more at who keeps the list in mind.
A survey of 3,000 US parents split the same thinking work into two kinds. Core work is daily and cannot be postponed: meals, cleaning, childcare, schedules and relationships. Episodic work, such as home maintenance or finances, can wait. Mothers handled 71 percent of all this cognitive labour and about 79 percent of the core work.
Core work is an ideal target for perfectionism because it never ends. Dean, Churchill and Ruppanner describe this load as invisible, boundaryless and enduring: nobody sees it, it does not stay within working hours, and it can never be finished.
Why "just tell me what to do" doesn't lighten the load
Many partners offer help in good faith: tell me, and I'll do it. The offer shares the doing, but the anticipating and monitoring stay with the person who first has to notice what to ask for and later check whether it happened.
Ocobock interviewed 81 US parents during the pandemic. In her analysis, cognitive labour is far from invisible to the women who do it. It only appears invisible to men because they use strategies to avoid it. Ocobock ties this to power: in her account, the arrangement sustains a structure that gives men power.
That reverses a familiar piece of advice. Exhausted parents are often told to let go and delegate. If the other adult accepts tasks but not responsibility from start to finish, letting go simply means the thing does not get done.
The expectations have grown
The sense of others' expectations is not only one parent's sensitivity. Curran and Hill's meta-analysis combined 164 samples of 41,641 American, Canadian and British university students from 1989 to 2016. All three forms of perfectionism became more common, and socially prescribed perfectionism grew the most.
Students are not parents, and averages that shift across cohorts say nothing about any one person. Today's parents of young children do, however, belong to the generations the data describe.
In a 42-country comparison that included Finland, parental burnout was more common in individualistic cultures. Individualism explained more of the difference between countries than economic inequality or family characteristics such as the number and age of children. One possible reading: where a child's success is seen as one parent's achievement, a child's struggle also feels like one parent's failure.
What you could try
The research describes associations, not a tested programme. The suggestions below are our editorial conclusions from the evidence above.
Checklist
- Ask whose expectation this is. When you notice yourself demanding something of yourself, consider whether the demand was ever said aloud or only assumed. An assumed expectation can be checked by asking.
- Hand over a whole responsibility, not a task. If the other adult takes on, say, dentist appointments, they also own remembering, booking and following up. Otherwise the anticipating stays with you.
- Lower one visible bar on purpose. Pick one thing where good enough is good enough, such as shop-bought cake for a birthday. See whether anyone notices.
- Get help if the tiredness doesn't lift. If exhaustion continues despite rest, raise it with your child health clinic, occupational health service or GP. You don't need a diagnosis to ask.
Next time you lie awake wondering what other people will think of tomorrow's packed lunch, ask a second question too: who else in this home knows that the lunch needs making?