Finnish 15-year-olds scored an average of 537 points in PISA 2018's financial literacy assessment. That tied them for second place with seven Canadian provinces, and only Estonia's 547 was statistically higher than everyone else's.
Two other numbers in the same Finnish report say more. Differences between Finnish schools were among the smallest in the whole study. Differences within schools were the largest. And a student's socioeconomic background shaped financial literacy in Finland more than in any other participating country but one.
So the gap does not open between schools. It opens inside them, and family background explains an unusually large part of it.
A more recent survey of 1,578 young Finns points the same way. The 15- to 29-year-olds asked in spring 2024 generally knew their way around money, but their knowledge varied with age, family background and gender.
If the gap is made at home, it is worth asking what happens at home when children learn about money. And before that: can teaching change what people actually do with money at all?
For years, knowledge did not seem to become behaviour
In 2014, Fernandes, Lynch and Netemeyer pooled 201 studies in a meta-analysis of financial education. The result was sobering. Education explained about 0.1 percent of the variation in financial behaviour, and even less in low-income samples. It also faded: about 20 months on, even large programmes had a negligible effect on behaviour.
That is where the idea that "knowledge isn't enough" took hold. The same paper made a suggestion that got less attention. The authors recommended "just-in-time" education: information delivered close to the decision it is meant to help.
Randomised trials tell a different story
Eight years later, Kaiser, Lusardi, Menkhoff and Urban narrowed the question to 76 randomised experiments with more than 160,000 participants in total. A randomised trial is the strongest way to separate the effect of teaching from the fact that people who already know more tend to sign up for courses, and keen schools tend to volunteer for pilots.
The result changed the picture. Financial education improved both knowledge and financial behaviour. The effects were clearly larger than earlier estimates, and they held when the researchers corrected for publication bias.
The two studies do not cancel each other out. Together they say that teaching can change how people handle money, but the effect does not maintain itself. Learning that never gets used is forgotten.
Finnish experiments: not everything game-like works
In Finland, economist Panu Kalmi has studied what financial education does. In his 2018 study, lower-secondary students used Oma Onni, an online environment with games, videos and other material. Their knowledge improved compared with a control group, but their saving showed no statistically significant change.
A broader comparison of 640 students in 42 schools set three game-based approaches against ordinary teaching. The design was not randomised. A clear effect on knowledge came from Yrityskylä, where students work inside a physical simulation of an economy. Oma Onni's effect was weak, and a mobile game did not stand out from ordinary teaching. Effects on students' own reports of how they handle money were weak.
Being game-like, then, is not what matters. What sets Yrityskylä apart is that decisions are made together, in a concrete setting, with visible consequences. That is our interpretation; the study did not test it separately.
Conversations at home show up in teenagers' confidence
The home's role has been studied with Finnish PISA data. In Silinskas, Ahonen and Wilska's analysis of 4,328 teenagers, both financial education at school and talking about money with parents were linked to teenagers' confidence in using financial services. That confidence was in turn linked to higher financial literacy scores.
The study measured test scores, not how teenagers actually use money, and it cannot establish cause and effect. It does show a route by which everyday conversations at home can surface in what young people know.
The habit of saving starts early. In an experiment with 115 four-year-olds, children were randomly assigned to groups, some of which went through a picture story about imagining the future. The children who imagined the future saved more in the study's task than the comparison group. It was a single session, not practice at home.
What this means at home
The just-in-time idea fits home better than school. At school, financial education is usually information delivered in advance. At home, the decision is already there: pocket money in the wallet, sweets on the shelf.
Talking about money does not require having a lot of it. A tight month can teach more than a comfortable one if the child sees how choices get made: which purchase waits, what gets dropped, and why. In Silinskas's analysis, the home factor was specifically talking about money with parents.
The suggestions below are our editorial conclusions from the evidence above, not methods tested as such.
Checklist
- Give children real, small decisions. Pocket money teaches only when it comes with a choice: what to buy, what to save for, what to give up.
- Talk about money at the moment of decision. A short question in the shop ("will this still stretch to next week?") lands exactly when knowledge can turn into action.
- Make the goal visible. A savings goal that stays in view keeps the future present in today's choices.
- Repeat. Learning fades if it happens once. A decision that comes round every week is practice; a one-off lesson is not.
In Finland, differences in financial literacy do not open between schools but within classrooms, and family background explains an unusually large share of them. Home is also where the moment happens: money in hand, and a decision to make.